Over the weekend, a nasty incident trended in social media. It involved the r-word, quoted below. The similarly nasty sentiments behind reactions to what happened may be familiar to some of you.
A couple had brought their four-year-old with developmental delays to a Yankees game. They captured it on video when a guy sitting in front of them turned around, after their boy likely kicked his seat, berated them and said, "Because your eff-ing child's retarded."
That's pretty despicable. So were some comments made when the NY Daily News posted its article on Facebook. "If this child is so sensitive and disabled, why did the parents bring him to a packed sports game?" asserted one guy. "Why would you take a developmentally disabled child to place that has screaming, yelling, people jumping around plus loud music and commentary?" noted another.
What?! The answer, of course, is: Exactly why you'd bring any child to a baseball game.
Here's how parents of children with disabilities and adults with disabilities responded when I asked them to explain, on Facebook, why a child with disabilities has the same right as anyone to enjoy public activities, events and spaces. I can't believe we even have to discuss this, let alone defend this, but sadly, we do.
"My goal–actually, I see it as my duty—as Amber's mom is to be sure she has a good life. That includes having fun doing things that all kids, teens and young adults enjoy. The reason being ADA is that all places, spaces, facilities and fun stuff needs to be barrier-free and accessible to everyone. We have a minor league baseball game in our county and Amber loves going to games. I would rather watch moss grow, but I don't go for myself. I am a mom, so I go because it makes my (adult) kid happy."—Teresa B.
"Our children can't learn to cope in environments that are difficult if they aren't exposed to them. If my child was loud, kicking a chair or seeming to be disruptive, usually I have said something like 'My son has autism and we are trying to figure out how to enjoy this movie/restaurant/baseball game/amusement park/etc.' For the most part, people have been respectful but I have had the 'If they can't behave, they shouldn't be here' comments to which my response is something along the lines of, 'Being rude isn't really behaving but they let you in."—Tracy C.
"Because our existence is not an inconvenience. Because your discomfort does not override our right to exist in public and enjoy public events. Because when your non disabled child yells or kicks a seat, the general public does not wonder why that child was allowed out of the house. Because we can."—Tara C.
"We've taken our son to NBA and NHL games regularly for nearly 20 years. We started as he loves watching the games on TV—even at a young age, he knew the players' names, jersey numbers and positions played. He developed an interest in both sports, and what parent wouldn't want to build on that interest?"—Lisa P.
"My daughter is a human being. That's why she has the same rights as anyone else to be anywhere in public. We had a moment in Ikea just the other day, when my daughter accidentally grabbed a display item and it couldn't be rung up. It was a Saturday morning, and there was a line of fifteen people behind me. It was just a notebook, nothing we needed. My daughter was working hard to process the disappointment, but what the world saw was this 14-yr-old yelling and storming off only to come back to yell some more. However, the young man behind me stepped in and offered to run a mile through Ikea to get a replacement notebook. I even said 'It's like a mile away' and he said 'It's okay, my sister is like your daughter.' Lucky us, we got the guy who 'got it' behind us in line. However, my daughter managed to process it all terrifically, and no new notebook was necessary. And I got to leave both proud of my daughter, but reminded that for every jackhole who yells at a 4-yr-old at the ballpark, there's this guy, willing to run a gauntlet for strangers."—Phoebe H.
"I work with kids both with and without additional needs (and I majored in special educaiton as well) and all I can think of is that my students should enjoy the same things as everyone else! My students, no matter what their background or needs or talents, all have the same rights. Kids are kids are by no means perfect. They are loud, they are squirmy, they are just trying to live and enjoy life like the rest of us. I hope that this event does not deter her or other families with kids with additional needs from going out and letting their kids know that they are valuable members of society. Don't let the haters get ya down!"—Priscilla B.
"We bring him because if all he has are limitations, he will never find his abilities."—Jill M.
"There are so many things my son can't experience like other kids that when we find something he enjoys, I'm not willing to deny him that feeling on the off chance that he might annoy someone. I am good about being proactive and introducing ourselves, and him, to people around us who might be affected if he gets loud (which is rare) and to just let us know if he's bothering them. So far, people respond very well to that and we haven't really had any problems. Knock on wood."—Amber M.
"I flew with my son who has CP and athetosis, constant movement. He tried so hard not to kick the seat in front of him, but it happened. The lady yelled at him to stop. I let it go the first time. The second time I told her, 'I will tell my child what he needs to do....' I have a shirt I used to put on him that said, 'Keep calm, it's only CP."—Alicia M.
"If you don't want to interact with all members of society, you have the right to be the one to stay at home."—Stef D.
I think what perplexes me about the whole situation is the amount of comments who are putting this on the child. Disabled or not, he's only 4 years old. Adults need to act like adults.
ReplyDeleteI was shocked by that too.
DeleteMany adults (like the ones at the game) have no tolerance for children unless their behavior is perfect, but they have no problem being rude, hurtful, obnoxious or impatient when something is less than perfect in their world (like a child screaming or kicking their seat). Seems pretty ironic that It's not socially acceptable for a kid to have a temper tantrum, but the annoyed adult feels justified in complaining and making a huge deal out of it.
ReplyDeleteTotally. This guy's reaction, along with some commenters, was unacceptable. Who has the behavior problem here?!
DeletePlus you would think the reason the family chose to attend the game is either a) the 4 year old wanted to go/has an interest in baseball/the Yankees b) other members of the family wanted to go and did not want to exclude him from a family outing or a combination of both. I will never understand why some people have issues with people with disabilities who may act a little differently in public- they are people first, or in this case kids first.
ReplyDeleteSo much intolerance out there, and a lack of understanding. Having the back of your seat kicked by a child—any child—may be annoying, but there are a whole lot of polite ways to ask parents to step in..
DeleteWhat I'm confused by is why the parents, according to other articles quoting them are demanding the Yankee organization apologize. This was a random fan not an employee of the organization.
ReplyDeleteAs far as kicking chairs - no the parent needs to make that stop. It is causing real physical pain to another person an no-one should be subjected to that for a prolonged length of time. If there is no way to stop it - then either you pay extra for bulkhead/front row, you buy an extra ticket for the seat in front of you to stay empty, a member of your party sits there and takes the physical assult.
She is upset because when she approached the employees at Yankee stadium for help they wouldn't help her. She asked if her seat could be moved or if there was somewhere else she could take her son and their basic was response was no and if she left the stadium to regroup there was no reentry. I am a former season ticket holder and I have seen first hand ushers and security remove people for abusive language. Regardless if this child was kicking his chair or not he bullied an berated a child. Judging by your response people like you are why we have to have discussions like this. If you can find any way to justify this then I feel sorry for you and those around you
DeleteYes, regardless, this guy acted like a total jerk. I think his question about why the parents demanded an apology is reasonable, you do wonder what happened. I also think his point is well taken about controlling a kicking child. I have been that parent who has had to control reactions from other people; kicking seats used to feel good to Max. While I obviously think there needs to be tolerance and understanding, it really can be annoying. Eventually, we learned to bring better distractions and pad Max's legs with jackets to muffle kicks.
DeleteWe had a similar experience a few weeks ago when I took my disabled daughter to the Regal Summer Dollar Movies near our house. She was screaming in the theater and people were quick to give looks and one lady was quick to be unkind outside of the theater, but it is so important to give our kiddos an experience at EVERYTHING and expose them to as much as possible!
ReplyDeletePaige
http://thehappyflammily.com
Amen to that!
DeleteThe Cleveland Cavaliers recently implemented a plan to be more inclusive for fans with special needs. I hope all teams take note:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.google.com/amp/s/www.sbnation.com/platform/amp/2017/3/31/15129734/cleveland-cavaliers-quicken-loans-arena-nba-sensory-inclusive
Props to them for creating a sensory inclusive arena! Yes, others should follow suit, ideally as a matter of practice and not after incidents occur.
DeleteYou censored the profanity in the quote but not the r word. I'm sure this was an oversight, but wanted to point it out so you can either put a content -note or censor the word. Thank you. -Tara C.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Tara, added note. Thanks, too, for contributing to this post.
DeleteSome people are so insensitive all people deserve to be out and about.
ReplyDeleteI used to take off my daughter's shoes on airplanes. That made the seat in front of her harder to reach, and the occasional random kick less annoying to the person in front of her.
ReplyDeleteBut I also see how discrimination comes through here, too...my daughter was always adorable and clearly had a disability. People almost always gave her the benefit of the doubt. Sometimes it was because I was working hard to keep her distracted and I generally spoke to people with a heads up before her actions became intrusive, but part of their good grace was just because she was cute. I always feel for other parents whose children look neuro-typical enough that ignorant people assume misbehavior goes unaddressed at home and it's their job to chastise the parents for their 'undisciplined' children. Often they are shockingly callous to kids doing their best. I generally say something caustic like, "Wow, you must have a shallow life to show such a shocking lack of empathy for a kid with a disability who is doing his best."